Every Major Utility Knife Brand, Ranked Worst To Best By User Reviews

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

When it comes to utility knives, it's easy to think they're all the same, right? For most users, they're just a handle, a blade, and a few quick cuts. But the truth is, not all knives are created equal, and the right brand can mean the difference between a tool you keep for years and one you toss in frustration after a week. We've ranked some of the top utility knife brands from worst to best, based on a combination of Amazon user ratings, review volume, and availability across major retailers like Home Depot, Lowe's, and Amazon itself.

A brand that's well-loved online, with plenty of models and consistently high scores, gets rewarded here. A brand with limited availability or lukewarm reviews, not so much. From everyday carry champions to jobsite workhorses, here's how the biggest names stack up, and why the top picks deserve a spot in your toolbox.

Gerber Gear is a name that will instantly ring a bell for pocket knife and multi-tool fans (Gerber actually integrated a tripod into a multitool), and it has successfully expanded into the utility knife space as well. Its compact designs, such as the Gerber EAB Lite, earn points for both portability and style. With an average Amazon rating hovering around 4.0 stars across its most popular utility knife SKUs, Gerber's offerings are appreciated by users who want a sturdy, easy-to-pocket tool for quick cuts on the go.

However, Gerber's lineup isn't huge, especially when compared to brands that dominate the shelves at big-box retailers. You'll find a handful of Gerber utility knife models online, but availability in hardware chains is hit or miss. The build quality received general praise in Amazon's review section, but the smaller blades and compact handles aren't always ideal for long cutting sessions or heavy-duty material. While Gerber Gear is a great backup knife brand, perfect for everyday carry enthusiasts or someone who wants a reliable folding utility knife, the limited variety and niche appeal mean you're better off looking higher on this list.

Slice is easily one of the most unique brands in the utility knife market, thanks to its ceramic blades that are marketed as finger-friendly. It's basically a fancy way of saying they're much safer to handle than traditional steel. Safety-conscious buyers and workplaces love them, which helps explain why many Slice utility knives pull in 4.6 to 5.0 star ratings on Amazon, while also being available at Target. They're especially popular in warehouses, schools, and offices, where the risk of injury is a big concern.

The ceramic edge stays sharp longer than most steel blades, and it won't rust, making these knives low-maintenance. However, this focus on safety and design comes at a cost, both literally and figuratively. Slice models tend to be pricier than standard retractable knives, and while they're great for cutting cardboard or light plastics, they simply can't match the raw cutting power of a fresh steel blade. If safety, style, and low maintenance are your top priorities, Slice deserves a look. But if you're in a trade that demands maximum cutting force, you'll quickly find the performance ceiling.

If you've ever sat in an art class, handled a craft project, or opened a model kit, you've probably crossed paths with X-Acto. Its precision knives are legendary in the creative world, with designs that prioritize fine control over brute strength. The brand has a stellar reputation in the crafting, architectural, and hobbyist circles, with many of their bestsellers pulling 4.6 to 4.7 stars from thousands of Amazon reviews. The praise includes sharp, easy-to-control blades and handles that feel like extensions of your hand.

As good as that sounds, X-Acto knives just aren't designed for the kind of abuse a jobsite utility knife faces. While they'll slice through paper, vinyl, or light plastics with ease, they're not the best choice for roofing shingles, drywall, or stubborn insulation. The handles, often made for precision, aren't as robust as the steel-bodied workhorses further up this list. That's not a knock against X-Acto. It remains one of the finest producers of high-quality blades and handles. If you need surgical precision in your cuts, X-Acto is at the top of the game. For heavy-duty cutting, it may be best to look elsewhere.

Fiskars has been around for centuries, and while it's better known for scissors, pruners, and cutting tools for gardeners, its Pro line of utility knives has made serious inroads with contractors and DIYers. Models like the Fiskars Pro Folding Utility Knife and the CarbonMax series consistently earn 4.6- to 4.7-star ratings on Amazon, with buyers praising comfortable grips, solid locking mechanisms, and long-lasting blades.

The standout here is ergonomics: Fiskars Pro knives are designed to reduce hand fatigue during extended use. That makes them a smart choice if you're working through a big project where dozens (or hundreds) of cuts are needed in a single day. They're also widely available online and at many hardware stores, so tracking one down is rarely a problem. Where Fiskars falls short is in variety. Compared to brands with dozens of SKUs, its utility knife catalog is relatively small. You'll find a few folding models and retractable options, but the breadth just isn't there. Still, if comfort and durability matter to you as much as raw cutting power, Fiskars Pro offers a very compelling package.

Tajima may not be a household name in the U.S., but among professionals who swear by Japanese-made tools, it's a brand that commands respect. Known for high-quality snap-off blade knives, Tajima products stand out for razor-sharp edges and robust construction. Popular models like the LC-650 pull in 4.3 to 4.8-star ratings on Amazon, with reviewers praising the clean, precise cuts and solid feel in hand.

Where Tajima shines is in build quality, as most of these knives feature metal-bodied construction with satisfying blade action. That's a far cry from the cheaper plastic-handled models you'll find at the bottom of bargain bins. However, availability is the brand's biggest hurdle in the U.S. market. While you can see its products online, spotting one in a physical big-box store can be tricky. As such, if you're willing to hunt for them, Tajima knives are a treat, especially for anyone who values precision and longevity in their tools. But because they're harder to find and lack the sheer variety of bigger U.S. brands, they land mid-pack in our ranking.

Irwin is a brand that feels like it's been around forever. It made SlashGear's list of underrated tool brands worth considering. Its utility knives are a natural extension of that legacy. With Amazon ratings averaging over 4.5 stars across hundreds of reviews, Irwin knives earn praise for being sturdy, comfortable to grip, and straightforward to use.

Irwin doesn't try to reinvent the wheel. Instead, its designs are classic, with solid locking mechanisms and easy blade changes. For everyday cutting tasks, they get the job done without fuss. The availability factor works in their favor, too; You can find Irwin utility knives in major hardware stores, online marketplaces, and even some general retail chains. However, Irwin's lineup isn't as expansive or innovative as some of the brands ahead of them. You won't see flashy one-handed openers or exotic materials here, just reliable, no-nonsense cutting tools. That makes them a safe, dependable choice, but not the one you'd pick if you're after cutting-edge features or the widest variety.

Husky is Home Depot's in-house tool brand, and if you've ever browsed their tool aisle, you've probably seen a few Husky utility knives on display. The brand earns between 4.6 and 4.7 stars via thousands of reviews, and that's no small feat given the sheer number of buyers picking them up for home projects. Their popularity largely comes from a mix of affordability and decent build quality. Essentially, you can get a sturdy folding or retractable Husky knife without spending much more than a fast-food meal.

Where Husky really shines is in accessibility. Since it's a Home Depot exclusive, it's practically guaranteed that you can walk into your nearest store and find a model or two ready to take home. The designs are straightforward and built for light to medium-duty work. The trade-off is that these aren't the knives you'll see most contractors swearing by on a jobsite. They're dependable, sure, but they don't have the same rugged feel or advanced features as higher-ranked brands. Still, for homeowners or casual DIYers, Husky is a reliable go-to brand.

Olympia Tools might not dominate conversations in tool forums, but their utility knives quietly do the job for plenty of users. With a focus on affordability, Olympia's lineup offers basic folding and retractable designs that hit the sweet spot for budget-conscious buyers. Ratings hover in the low-to-mid 4-star range, with customers often calling them surprisingly good for the price.

You'll find Olympia Tools in various online marketplaces, though they don't have the same shelf presence as Stanley or Milwaukee. The knives themselves are functional, with comfortable grips and decent blade locking systems. For everyday tasks like cutting rope, opening packages, or light craft work, they're more than up to the task. As you might expect, the downside here is that Olympia isn't pushing boundaries in durability or design innovation. They don't offer a huge variety of models, and if you put them side-by-side with a premium brand's heavy-duty knife, the difference in materials and longevity is noticeable. They earn this mid-list spot for being a solid, no-frills option that won't let you down for lighter jobs.

Lenox Tools is a brand that's actually owned by Stanley Black and Decker. While you'll often hear about them in the context of saw blades, they also make a mean utility knife. Their designs focus on durability and cutting performance, with features like titanium-coated blades and reinforced handles. On Amazon, popular models often score around 4.4 stars, with users praising their longevity and how sharp they stay between blade changes.

The build quality of a Lenox knife is immediately apparent. They feel solid in hand, and the locking mechanisms are strong enough to inspire confidence when you're cutting through stubborn materials like insulation, roofing felt, or heavy carpet. They also have a reputation for blade retention, which means fewer mid-project swaps. Where Lenox falls a bit short is in variety. The lineup isn't massive, so you won't find as many options as you would with Stanley or OLFA. Still, if you need something that's going to last and perform consistently under pressure, Lenox deserves a spot in your toolbox.

Stanley isn't just one of the best hand tool brands out there; It is practically synonymous with utility knives. In fact, they're credited with inventing the modern retractable utility knife, and that legacy still carries weight today. Their models span from budget-friendly basics to more premium designs, and their availability is unmatched. You can literally buy Stanley knives in hardware stores, big-box retailers, and online marketplaces everywhere.

Amazon reviews for their most popular models range from 4.5 to 4.8 stars, with praise focused on reliability, ease of blade changes, and comfortable grips. Contractors and DIYers alike know exactly what they're getting with Stanley: a knife that works, lasts, and is easy to replace or upgrade when needed. If there's a downside, it's that some of the entry-level models can feel a bit dated compared to the ergonomic, feature-packed knives offered by brands higher up this list. But as an all-around choice for virtually any cutting task, Stanley is tough to beat. Its dominance in both reviews and availability earns it a high spot here.

DeWalt's reputation in the tool world is built on rugged, jobsite-ready gear, and their utility knives are no exception. Whether it's a folding model or a retractable heavy-duty option, DeWalt knives typically score 4.6 stars and up on Amazon and rack up hundreds of reviews. While they offer an excellent warranty, the products themselves come with high praise. They're built tough, comfortable to use, and the blade mechanisms are smooth and secure.

DeWalt also wins points for innovation, often adding small but smart touches like integrated blade storage or one-handed opening designs. For professionals, these are the kinds of features that make a real difference throughout a workday. Availability is excellent, too, since you can find them in virtually every major hardware chain and online store. The only thing keeping DeWalt from going higher is that while they excel in durability, their knives don't quite reach the same precision-focused performance as our top two picks. Still, if you want a knife that can handle abuse and keep going, DeWalt is a brand you can trust without hesitation.

Milwaukee has built a loyal following in the tool community, and its Fastback series utility knives are a big reason why. With one-handed opening, comfortable ergonomics, easy blade switching, and tough construction, these knives are designed to keep up with demanding work. Amazon ratings back that up, with most models sitting in the 4.7 to 4.8-star range with plenty of reviews praising their ease of use.

Milwaukee's edge (pun intended) comes from thoughtful design. The Fastback's smooth deployment, strong locking, and integrated additional tools make it a multitasker on the jobsite. Availability is strong across major retailers, and their variety of models means there's likely a Milwaukee utility knife that fits your exact needs. Better yet, a single tool can be used for multiple DIY tasks, too. While they don't quite match OLFA in sheer blade precision or variety, Milwaukee scores high for durability, user-friendly features, and consistent quality. For anyone who values both function and strength, it's a brand that's hard to pass up.

When it comes to precision and performance, OLFA sits comfortably at the top. The brand pioneered the snap-off blade design, and its knives have become a staple in everything from construction work to graphic design studios. On Amazon, OLFA's flagship models regularly earn 4.7 to 4.8 stars, with thousands of glowing reviews highlighting razor-sharp edges, comfortable handles, and long-lasting blades.

One of OLFA's biggest strengths is variety. Unlike other brands on this list, its catalog includes everything from heavy-duty construction blades to slim, art-focused craft knives. This range, combined with consistent availability across online and retail channels, makes them a top pick for professionals and hobbyists alike. What sets OLFA apart is the feeling you get the first time you slice through something with one of their knives: it's clean, effortless, and precise. Add to that, while other brands might beat them on ruggedness or flashy features, OLFA's unmatched cutting performance and attention to detail make them the clear #1 in this ranking.

To rank these utility knife brands from worst to best, we focused on measurable, publicly available data rather than subjective impressions. Each brand's placement is based on three core factors: average Amazon user ratings, review volume, and product availability across major retailers like Amazon, Home Depot, Lowe's, and Walmart. Average ratings reflect overall customer satisfaction, while review volume gives a sense of how widely used and tested the products are in real-world conditions. Availability plays an equally important role, since a great utility knife isn't very useful if it's hard to find or only sold through niche channels.

By weighing these elements together, we created a ranking that balances quality, popularity, and accessibility. A brand with consistently high ratings, plenty of customer feedback, and strong retail presence naturally scores higher, while those with limited availability, fewer SKUs, or weaker user reviews rank lower. This ensures the list reflects not just performance, but how well these knives serve the needs of the largest number of buyers.