Common Mistakes Almost Everyone Makes When Shopping At Menards

When preparing to tackle a home improvement project, be it a quick weekend DIY fix or a major renovation, stores like Menards are the essential first stop for home improvement products. Their vast inventories span everything from lumber and hardware to appliances and seasonal decor. However, the scale and operational quirks of a major chain like Menards mean that even the savviest shoppers can easily fall prey to common, costly mistakes.

Before you even set foot in the store or click "add to cart" on their website, you need to know the rules at Menards. The store has several policies and standards that distinguish it from competitors such as Home Depot and Lowe's. They're not difficult once you get the hang of them, but they are a surprise at first.

All the 11% off signage can be confusing if you're new to Menards. The famous deal isn't as simple as taking something to the register. The promotion isn't an immediate price cut at the point of sale, but a deferred discount. This means you have to pay the full, regular price for your items upfront. That can be seen as misleading since it has not always been clear.

Instead of instant savings, the cashier hands you a separate voucher printed at the bottom of your main receipt. To actually get your 11% savings, you then have to navigate a somewhat old-school mail-in rebate process. 

Customers need to get a physical form, which you can pick up at the customer service desk or print from their website, fill it out entirely by hand, put the original receipt in there, buy a postage stamp, and mail the envelope through standard mail to a special P.O. Box in Elk Mound, Wisconsin. After waiting from six to eight weeks, you'll receive a store merchandise credit check rather than cash or credit to your payment card.

It is understandable to accidentally toss that long rebate receipt or lose it while you are busy with a home improvement project. It is easy to assume your money is gone for good if that tiny piece of paper disappears, especially since Menards' instructions say you need the original. However, do not panic if you misplace or accidentally throw out your physical receipt.

Menards has been dealing with many lawsuits surrounding policy confusion, but the company has a pretty simple digital way to get your transaction details back if you paid with a credit card, debit card, or even a check. Head to a Return Receipt Kiosk, swipe your card, and find your past purchases. Or, sign in to your Menards account, where you can access your purchase history by linking the specific card you used to pay.

Once you locate the transaction, either online or at the kiosk, you can print a replacement receipt without any fuss. Just make sure to include a quick note in your envelope explaining that the original receipt was lost. It might take a bit longer for the rebate center to check and process these reprinted receipts, but you will still get your merchandise credit check in the mail eventually.

When you're making your way through Menards' huge aisles, check out the Ray's List section. This was named after the company's founder, Ray Menard, and it is a clearance goldmine. It's where Menards puts its oops or mis-tinted paint, slightly dinged or dented appliances, open-box merchandise, and former store display models. You'll also find highly specific special orders that previous customers customized but never picked up or returned.

For those who prefer online shopping, Ray's List is also fully integrated into the Menards website and mobile app. The digital version lets you easily filter available clearance stock by your local store, product category, brand, and price. You should always hit up Ray's List first before paying full price, because you can save a massive amount of cash here if you don't mind a few minor cosmetic dings, like a scratch or a dent.

We've all bought something only to see it go on sale soon after. While other stores will leave you feeling frustrated, Menards will give you a partial refund. Instead of feeling buyer's remorse, smart shoppers know they can get back the difference between what they paid and the new sale price. That's great when you're looking for gadgets at Menards that may go on sale.

Your item must have been bought within 14 days before the sale started. Also, you need your original receipt or a reprinted version to get this done. Menards won't give you cash for these adjustments. Instead, you'll get a Menards Merchandise Credit Check, and that's only good for future in-store purchases.

The policy generally applies to items you bought at full price and are in the current sale flyer. That means you can't get an adjustment on items that were already on clearance or previously discounted. Also, some purchases are completely off-limits for the program, things like gift cards, event tickets, propane, delivery and handling charges, and rental items.

You may not be aware, but a 2x4 at the lumber yard isn't literally 2 x 4 inches; it's 1.5 x 3.5 inches. If you really need those full, actual dimensions, you'll have to check out their hardwoods or plane the wood down yourself. This isn't a marketing trick unique to one store; actual sizes are almost always smaller than nominal dimensions.

The term nominal means the dimensions of the lumber right after it's rough-cut from the log at the sawmill, before any finishing. Since wood is organic, it holds a lot of moisture when it's first cut. To ensure every board on the shelf is uniform, smooth, and safe to handle, the mills run that dried wood through a planer, surfacing all four sides.

This crucial step shaves off about half an inch from the thickness and the width, leaving you with the actual or dressed size you see neatly stacked in the aisles. So, if you need exact sizes, you'll have to do some cutting of your own. While you are looking there, you might as well look for useful carpentry tools for your lumber.