Riding Vs. Stand-On Lawn Mower: Which Do Experts Say Perform The Best?

Add SlashGear on Google:
Google Discover

Mowers come in two varieties: Riding tractor-style or standing configurations. There are conventional models and zero-turn versions of each, too, with the latter having a zero degree turning radius, meaning they can make sharp, sudden changes. But which is better? What do experts say is the ideal mower to use? Unless you're a professional mowing for profit, the true answer is whichever you prefer. Standing mowers are the top choice for high precision and complex landscaping, but the trade-offs of using one may not be worth it if you're just mowing your own yard, especially if there's lots of ground to cover.

Brian Fullerton, from Brian's Lawn Maintenance and Lawntrepreneur Academy, has been in the business since 2007 and seems to know his stuff. He says that each type is suited to a particular scenario. Regarding performance, they are similar, though Brian says "If I have to mow smaller properties [...] I'm gonna' go with a stand-on mower every single time." Adversely, he says for large properties or wide open sites, he'd go with a sit down model, opting for one with a larger deck to cover more ground. 

Ron Scheffler, the Senior Product Manager of mowers for Bobcat, says much the same, advising people to assess the properties they're maintaining before choosing a mower type. If you're mowing in urban areas or tight spaces with complex landscaping, navigating gated sections, or dealing with more obstacles, a standing mower offers improved maneuverability. 25-year mowing veteran Gene Caballero tells Homes and Gardens that standing models are also useful for quick transitions, perfect for those times when you're frequently hopping off to pick up toys or debris, for instance.

The drawbacks of standing versus sit-down mowers

Assuming you're selecting a zero-turn model of either a sit-down or standing mower, the biggest drawback between the two that will affect your experience has to do with comfortability. That's precisely why the experts recommend sit-down options for larger properties and covering more lawn space. It's as simple as you get to sit while you work, while standing puts stress on your body that can become uncomfortable during lengthier projects.

A practical drawback to also consider is that standing mowers don't usually allow you to bag up or catch grass clippings, and those that do come with catchers may not hold as much. They're more expensive upfront, as well, since standing mowers are preferred by professional landscapers and mowing companies. That said, there are residential stand-on mowers available.

But none of this automatically makes sit-down mowers better. There are drawbacks on the other side of the equation, too. Because you're sitting down and have a lower view, you may have a harder time seeing the terrain, objects, and nearby landscaping. Sit-down mowers also tend to be much less precise. Zero-turn sit-down models are still bigger, too, which can make precise cuts or fitting into smaller spaces more challenging. 

Also, because of their size, they take up more storage space, so you'll need a big enough shed or garage area, or a larger trailer, although that's a disadvantage of larger zero-turn mowers overall when compared to push mowers, regardless of stand up or sit-down designs.

Sit down mowers may be safer, and how you choose

Husqvarna also points out a relevant factor when considering sit-down versus standing options. Standing models are technically safer since you're located near the rear of the mower. You can also dismount quickly if you need to, most notably during emergencies, as well as hop off to clear debris, avoid fixtures and landscaping, and reduce accidents. You can see better, too, since you have a higher viewing angle.

Moreover, stand up mowers tend to handle inclines, steep terrain, and uneven areas better, and it's easier to ride over these areas because you can shift your body weight as needed, compensating for the steeper grades. Though, there is always a small risk of falling off or experiencing fatigue after standing for long periods, and both are concerns worth noting. On a sit-down mower, going over tough terrain, the machine is doing most of the work. Nevertheless, the handful of advantages attributed to stand-on mowers can indeed makes them more desirable to some.

So, what's the verdict? Ultimately, you should decide based on the size and complexity of your property. Experts like Scheffler, Fullerton, or Caballero all recommend sit-down models for when you want maximum efficiency and better comfort during long rides. They also may be preferable when the property is large enough to warrant the sizable frame of a sit-down mower, or as Bob Vila editors describe it, when you have "a yard like a football field." If your property is smaller, with more complex landscaping or tight areas, a stand up mower would likely be more accommodating.

Recommended