Thursday, Aug 30th 2007 by Chris Davies


Worth Reading?


YesNo


+22 [30 votes]
Loading ... Loading ...

No handset in the RAZR range has managed to capture the same excitement as that which met the original V3, and Motorola has been accused of resting on their laurels and relying on past glories instead of true innovation.  The MOTORAZR2, then, is part evolution and part attempted revolution; Motorola recognising that, while the same ethos of “slim & sexy” might kick-start design, these days you need true features if you want to win sales.  Sprint sent over their version of the MOTORAZR2, the V9m, and asked us to be honest about whether this descendant lives up to its heritage.

Motorola MOTORAZR2 V9m on Sprint

Sprint's MOTORAZR2 V9m package 

I can still remember the excitement I felt when I first saw photos of Motorola’s original RAZR V3.  Months before release, in fact before Motorola themselves were even admitting to its existence, it was so very different from anything else on the market - so slim and yet feature-packed - that I knew I had to have it.  It’s seldom that such an overwhelming feeling takes you over, particularly when the world has moved on to the stage where manufacturers compete, with straight-faced hyperbole, with a shaved half-millimetre here or a dropped gram there.  With customers so used to super-slim handsets there’s no way the V9m could manage the same wowing introduction; instead - and for the better - Motorola has had to work hard to boost the features, interface and overall feel of the cellphone in order to make it competitive.

MOTORAZR2 V9m

That’s not to say the chassis of the V9m is a let down.  Ironically, thanks to a piece of hardened glass covering the front display and a full metal casing, at 4.1oz it actually weighs more than the original, but the shape as a whole is more streamlined and thankfully without that protruding antenna bulge at the bottom.  You’ll be glad of the glass cover, too, once you get a look at the stunning external display; at 2-inches and 65,000 colours it’s better than some cellphones manage for their primary screen.  Moto haven’t missed a trick in making it as functional as possible, either: obviously you see network status, caller ID and the usual updates, but it’ll also show album art and mp3 details, play videos with surprisingly high quality, and work as self-portrait viewfinder for the 2-megapixel camera. 

Motorola V9m

The bottom slice of the screen is touch-sensitive and can trigger applications from standby or control playlists when enjoying media.  Not only that, but finger-jab accuracy is improved thanks to vibrating tactile feedback.  Disappointingly it’s only that lower panel that responds to touch; the rest is plain screen, but at least the side-mounted “smart” key, volume and shutter controls take advantage of the tactile feedback too.

Open up, and inside there’s another display that’s pretty much the equal - rather than any better - of that on the lid; 2.2-inches and curiously CDMA customers are expected to make do with 65k colours rather than the GSM version’s 262k.  The interface, however, is such a pleasant surprise for those fearing the old-school OS that you soon forget all else.  Thanks to some Sprint fettling it both looks and works far better than that of previous handsets, with classy but non-distracting animations and rich colour reproduction.  Key feel and response is improved also, with the same zero-profile buttons but a greater amount of stroke.

Motorola MOTORAZR2 V9m on Sprint

In fact the whole OS has seemingly been refreshed; the phonebook, which was a major source of frustration before, has been brought up to date with space for five numbers, email and postal addresses, web URL and more in each contact (rather than requiring separate entries for each detail).  In terms of other features it’s a pretty standard collection - email, IM, voice recorder, calculator, the usual - but that’s not to say anything manages less than satisfactory performance.  The camera, no headline feature with a mere 2-megapixels and lacking autofocus and flash, nonetheless produces reasonable images that can be transferred via Bluetooth, MMS picture-message, printed directly to a compatible printer or set as wallpaper or contact image.  It’ll also record video, saving clips as long as the 65MB of internal memory (or however large a microSD card you invest in) can store.

MOTORAZR2 V9m

The major advance since the launch of the V3 has been the growing prevalence of high-speed cellular data connections, and the V9m is well-placed to take advantage of the media Sprint offers.  With a 3G EV-DO connection and using the carrier’s PowerVision network the V9m handles streaming audio and video, music downloads and pay-per-view without a hiccup.  We found quality was just as good whether you viewed content on the internal or external screen, and you can thankfully cut the headphone cord since the MOTORAZR2 supports the Bluetooth A2DP wireless-stereo profile.  Sprint, however, don’t even include a wired handsfree kit.

As for performance, we found the V9m demonstrated the usual sound quality we’ve come to expect from Sprint; signal grip is decent and even when using the speakerphone the audio on both ends is fair.  The volume seemingly cranks higher than many of its rivals, and happily without any particular distortion, and while there’s only a single on-board speaker music playback is okay for casual use.  Motorola rate the MOTORAZR2 V9m’s battery as managing 3.6hrs talk-time or 12 days standby, and while we’ve not been using it for long enough to say for sure, it looks as though it will come near that.

Sprint's MOTORAZR2 V9m package

In terms of the package from Sprint, we have to say that we’ve seen better.  Considering the V9m costs (as of writing) $249.99 thanks to a $150 rebate, it’d be nice to see more than just the charger, a USB data cable and a 256MB microSD card (plus adaptor).  Even the original V3 came with a handsfree kit!

Overall, though, the MOTORAZR2 V9m did enough to rejuvenate our interest in the venerable V range, something that up until recently seemed an impossible task.  Motorola have thankfully seen the light and realised that it’ll take more than interminable colour options to keep its range fresh; what they’ve given us instead is an attractive, capable handset that, while not attracting as many glances as the V3 first did, certainly didn’t make us ashamed to carry.

Thanks to Sprint for providing the V9m for review

Subscribe via RSS or Email | Read 96 times | PRINT THIS ENTRY


  1.  Eric   View all comments by Eric  +1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    I’d say be lucking you got the card.

    I picked up a blackberry 8830 from Verizon, and It didn’t come with a card and it was $50 more after rebated. Granted the markup on a BB probably isn’t as much as a Razr. From previous experience I was shocked the BB came with the data cable, VZW likes to bilk you out of $20 usually. I know they tried to get me to buy a case. good thing we opened it up, and it came with one.

    Seems to me all the stuff you don’t like it is fairly acceptable for the price point. A mere 2 megapixel camera? the lack of a wired hands free kit? Does anybody use those? I’m not being sarcastic, I haven’t seen anyone use those since the “cellphones cause brain cancer” scare of the early 2000’s.

    You guys know more about Razr’s than me, so compared to what it’s predecessors you may be right about it lacking some features or coming up short. But for the price point and the feature list it seems fairly acceptable to me. It won’t make me jump networks or switch phones, but there is a world of difference between a BB and a Razr, so that’s not exactly a fair comparison for me to make.

    It’s a good point to make about freshening the Razr, they seemingly have(had) become far to ubiquitous around here to be viewed anything other than a really thin phone.

  2.  Chris Davies   View all comments by Chris Davies  +3  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    Thanks for the feedback, Eric. My point about the lack of handsfree was more to do with the fact that the V9m is branded as a music/media phone, and yet there’s no way to enjoy stereo sound out of the box. I realise a lot of people prefer to use their own headphones anyway, but considering how cheap a set must be to Motorola it seems a shame not to throw a pair in for the sake of making it instantly usable.

    As for the 2-megapixel camera, yes, there are competing products out there with the same or worse quality, but this is meant to be Motorola’s new flagship clamshell. They really need to step up their game if they want to win back the users they lost from rolling out the same old mediocre hardware just in different coloured casings.

    I don’t mean to sound hard - in fact I have something of a soft spot for Moto; my first phone in fact was a 1st-gen StarTAC - I just want them to get back to innovating rather than relying on old achievements.

  3.  Eric   View all comments by Eric  -2  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    That’s a good point about it being their flagship media phone with the headphones et al.
    I’m not a media phone person per say. I’m more of a PDA/Smartphone person. I transfered the Rolling Stones 40 Licks album on a card to my phone, and I’ve listened to like 3 songs. So that tells you where I’m coming from.

  4.  Doug   View all comments by Doug  -1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    Thanks for the review. This is looking pretty slick.

    So let’s say I snap a couple pictures and record a couple videos. How do I get them off the phone? Do I have to send them through Sprint’s server and get charged for the data transfer, or can I connect a USB cable straight to my computer and do a quick & simple transfer?

  5.  Jeff   View all comments by Jeff  +1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    My main curiosity about these Motorazr2’s are the insides. I notice the Sprint one is the V9m with the 225mhz processor and a bit modified memory and video display difference than the V9 that AT&T is offering with the 500mhz. I saw this phone displayed at the Motorola site awhile ago and was amped for it. Can’t decide to upgrade my sprint phone to this V9m, or go switch to AT&T with their seemingly stronger V9 model but it’s ‘mahogany’ which is awfully close to pink. Any insight on don’t worry about the hardware difference or quality of AT&T to Sprint preference, added to the ‘pink’ factor? :)

  6.  kiki   View all comments by kiki  +1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    i just just upgraded my phone for the motorazr2 from sprint from the samsung a900. i love the phone! the design is cool and the picture quality is great! the only thing that disappoints me about the phone is that its not a texter friendly phone and i text alot! and the fact that there isn’t more things that you can do with the external display other than watch videos and music and the fact that you cant listen to music with headphones/ other than that, i like it

  7.  Dunc   View all comments by Dunc  +1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    Hmmm - I have just received my V9 and must say I am much impressed. I think that something that needs to be addressed in reviews is durability. I have had a number of mobiles in my life, and initially was of the opinion that Motorola had to be avoided at all costs as their early phones were shocking. Nokia, instead, were the phone of choice. However times have really changed. My last 3 phones have been Moto’s and with the V3 they hit on the really important factor of having the phone last. Nokia have really dipped in their product quality, where Moto have really improved. The Moto menu systems are now on par with Nokia for ease of use, and their handsets look a damn sight better!

    I agree, however, that Moto need to not rest on past success but continue to innovate. I beleive that they have achieved this with the V9, but the camera really does need improvement. As a flagship product it should really have features such as auto focus and flash.

    All up though, I think that the V9 is GORGEOUS. It is very user friendly and sits comfortably in my pocket - I love it!

  8.  Chris Davies   View all comments by Chris Davies  +1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    So let’s say I snap a couple pictures and record a couple videos. How do I get them off the phone? Do I have to send them through Sprint’s server and get charged for the data transfer, or can I connect a USB cable straight to my computer and do a quick & simple transfer?

    Motorola bundle a USB data cable with the V9, so you should be able to transfer directly to your PC.

    I think that something that needs to be addressed in reviews is durability.

    Thanks for the feedback, Dunc. Unfortunately durability is one of those tricky things to address, since we generally don’t live with the handset long enough prior to writing the review itself to find out if there are any inherent weak points in the design. Obviously we could delay the review until we’ve lived with it for a number of months, but then by that time the market has usually changed and people are interested in the next “big thing”. And often the phone company wants their handset back before then anyway!

    What we do try to give is a reasonable first-impression of durability, based on having handled a whole lot of phones and so comparing, say, a plastic body to a metal one. If we manage to keep the handset long enough and come across issues - whether in build quality, software or anything else - you can be sure we’ll revisit the review and update it.

  9.  Steve   View all comments by Steve  +1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    I’ve had the V9m for about two weeks now and I gotta say I love it. This thing is absolutely incredible to LOOK at…Ive never said that about a phone before. and I have NEVER heard such clarity from a cell phone. I am not crazy about the ‘reflective’ front and yeah, it does get alot of fingerprints, but overall this phone is fantastic. I think if I went with anything else now, I’d be very disappointed.

  10.  Joelle   View all comments by Joelle  Neutral  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    i just received the new motorazr2 v9m and i absolutely love the phone. it is slimmer than the razr v3 which i had and loved, but the touch screen and bigger regular screen make it so much more appealing. my last razor lasted me two years and went through hell, if this phone lasts that long i will be more than pleased.

  11.  Squiggy   View all comments by Squiggy  +1  Add karma Subtract karma Quote

    You got a data cable? I didn’t! I bought the car charger from sprint 31 bucks. Their book is way flawed. It says to download the music manager from sprint, Guess what there is no site http://www.sprintdownload.com does not exist . So I go to the sprint site to find the music manger a differant route guess what they don’t have aV9M phone on there to pick. I call sprint support ask them how do I get the music in the phone, They tell me I have to buy it in which they will charge me for the download and the mins I use. What a joke ! Call another support they tell me the same thing and knowone is formlar with the V9m. Finaly I had to drag all the songs over to the music file and it finaly worked. I’m happy with the phone but hate sprint. Oh did I happen to mention that the interface for sprint is differant than all the other Razor2s. So don’t go to Moto for any help they don’t have it on their site either. Sheesh Did i mention that my girl friend is a sprint sales person? Never again with Sprint


Add your comments

Fill in the required fields below to leave a comment or login to your account. If you haven't signed up, you can do so free here. With SlashGear account, you will be able to participate on SlashGear Forums discussion.






Close
E-mail It
About / Advertise / Contact / Archives / Privacy Policy / Terms of Use
Copyright © 2006-2008 SlashGear, All Rights Reserved.