Google engineer explains why Android UI will never be as fluid as iOS or WP7

Dec 6, 2011
68

Recent Google engineering intern Andrew Munn has launched into a detailed explanation on Google+ as to why many Android devices are significantly more sluggish and less responsive in terms of user interface and experience than comparable iOS and Windows Phone 7 devices. The root of the problem? Inoptimal priority queuing on Android OS. On one side, iOS has graphics rendering queued as a real-time priority, thereby letting users self-manage which priorities are to be rendered in the background. On the flip side, Android views graphics rendering as a normal priority. As a result, Android devices tend to become more sluggish when they're trying to perform other tasks simultaneously.

The gist of the problem boiled down by Munn:

It’s not GC pauses. It’s not because Android runs bytecode and iOS runs native code. It’s because on iOS all UI rendering occurs in a dedicated UI thread with real-time priority. On the other hand, Android follows the traditional PC model of rendering occurring on the main thread with normal priority.

Munn also broke it down in real world terms by providing the example that if you put your finger on the screen of an iPhone or iPad and move it around when it's halfway through loading a complex web page like Facebook, all rendering stops instantaneously. The website will literally never load until your finger is removed, and this all boils down to the fact that the "UI thread is intercepting all events and rendering the UI at real-time priority."

There are also some other reasons, like inoptimal hardware. The NVIDIA Tegra 2 CPUs ubiquitous to many Android 3.0 tablets and some phones suffered from low memory bandwidth and lacked NEON media instructions, both of which ultimately presented a bottleneck to the Android user interface and experience. However, Android 4.0 remedies this by having graphics hardware acceleration, although as long as graphics aren't given top priority (a la real-time), platforms like iOS or Windows Phone 7 are always going to be more fluid.

[via Google+]


Must Read Bits & Bytes